You can’t go wrong with your good ole’ slow cooker when it comes to making baked beans for a crowd! This tried and true slow cooker baked beans recipe is loaded with brown sugar and bacon and makes enough for the whole gang at your next summer gathering.
This is a sponsored conversation on behalf of Simply Beverages and Pringles; all opinions and text are my own. Thank you for supporting the brands that support this site!
Slow Cooker Baked Beans
Lazy summer days all seemed to run together when I was little, so the summer cookouts sprinkled across our calendar were always events I looked forward to. Of course, I enjoyed seeing distant family members and playing with cousins I might see only a few times a year, but make no mistake, I was really in it for the food…
Whether we were celebrating a holiday or a family reunion, the menus all looked pretty similar, but I didn’t mind in the least. Because I knew some of my favorite foods were sure to make an appearance — namely this cream corn casserole and my mom’s baked beans recipe. I use the term “recipe” loosely, because like so many of my favorite family recipes, up until just this week there was no actual written recipe.
I think that’s part of the charm of recipes that have been passed down over the years. No two family members make them exactly the same, but it’s those small variations each time that make the dish special. However, I know most home cooks prefer to work from a written recipe (I swing back and forth depending on the dish myself), so I sat down and wrote out my mom’s baked beans recipe, making a few adaptations to convert what was traditionally an oven-baked baked beans recipe to slow cooker baked beans.
Why the slow cooker? Well, for a number of reasons, starting with the fact that I don’t have to heat up the oven on a hot summer day. And this baked bean recipe is far more transportable this way, especially if you have one of the slow cookers that feature a locking lid. The ceramic insert will keep them hot for hours, whether you have an outlet available or not. And finally, it makes a BIG batch of baked beans EASY!
Making Slow Cooker Baked Beans for A Crowd
With five kids, big batch recipes are kind of a way of life for me. In fact, I often wonder how I’ll ever go back to cooking for just my husband and me someday… Never fear, I’m going to share a scaled down version of this baked beans recipe that you can double to feed a crowd or prepare as is for a family dinner. AND I’m even going to throw in the oven-baked baked beans instructions, because I know some of you might prefer to make them that way.
Whether you’re making the recipe as is or scaling it up, you can save yourself some serious cash by stocking up on canned pork and beans at Sam’s Club. They carry an eight-pack that will yield two recipes’ worth of slow cooker baked beans or one large double recipe — all at their fabulously low bulk pricing. If you’re hosting a cookout, it only makes sense to turn your trip into a one-stop stock up shop, by snagging your chips, drinks (my kids love the big bottles of Simply Lemonade®), and desserts for the occasion at the same time.
And if you use the Scan and Go app or In-Club Pick Up, you’ll be in and out in almost no time at all. I am seriously in love with these convenient features! No more long checkout lines for me.
Baked Beans Like Mom Makes Them
Six ingredients — that’s all you need to make this yummy slow cooker baked beans recipe. As I mentioned earlier, it starts with canned pork and beans. I’m not a huge fan of semi-homemade recipes, but this is one where it totally works.
Start by opening the cans and draining off the excess liquid from the top. This will keep the baked beans from being too soupy after cooking. To the beans we’re going to stir in dark brown sugar, ketchup, mustard, chopped onion, and some chopped up bacon slices.
But wait! There’s a secret you need to know about the bacon. After you chop it up, spread it on a paper towel on a microwave safe plate. Place another paper towel on top and microwave it for one minute to remove some of the excess bacon grease. NOW you can add it to the baked beans mixture…
Cook on high in your slow cooker for about four hours, stirring occasionally. The baked beans may seem a bit liquidy when they’re finished cooking, but they will thicken up as they cool off. You can also sit the slow cooker lid on slightly askew for the last 30 minutes or so to allow some of the liquid to evaporate, which will also help them thicken up.
You can’t go wrong with your good ole’ slow cooker when it comes to making baked beans for a crowd! This tried and true crock pot baked beans recipe is loaded with brown sugar and bacon and makes enough for the whole gang at your next summer gathering.
- 4 (16.5-oz.) cans pork and beans, liquid drained off top
- 6 slices bacon, chopped
- 3/4 cup dark brown sugar
- 1/4 cup ketchup
- 2 teaspoons mustard
- 1 large onion, roughly chopped
- Open the cans of pork and beans and drain the excess liquid off the top. Pour the remaining contents into your slow cooker insert.
- Chop the bacon slices and place them on a microwave safe paper towel-lined plate. Lay another piece of paper towel on top and microwave for one minute to remove the excess bacon grease.
- To the pork and beans, stir in the dark brown sugar, ketchup, mustard, chopped onion, and partially cooked bacon.
- Slow cooker instructions: Place the lid on the slow cooker, and cook on high for about four hours, stirring occasionally. With about 30 minutes left to cook, set the lid on slightly askew to allow some of the excess liquid to cook off. Allow the baked beans to cool slightly to thicken up before serving.
- Oven baked instructions: Pour the baked beans mixture into a 2-quart casserole dish. Baked at 375 degrees, uncovered, for one hour. Allow to cool slightly before serving to thicken up.
This recipe doubles easily to feed a crowd! Doubling it in the slow cooker will extend the cook time to about 8 hours, stirring occasionally.
Need some inspiration beyond burgers and brats for your next cookout? A few of my faves are this easy chicken salad recipe, these marinated tri-tip beef kebabs (you won’t believe how simple these are!), and these BBQ chicken foil packets. You can pick up the ingredients for all of them at Sam’s Club, along with your pork and beans, snacky items (like Cheez-it® Duoz and/or Pringles®), and some cold Simply Lemonade® to wash it all down!