Make your own homemade uncrustables frozen PB&J sandwiches part of your weekly meal prep day... And YOU control the quality of the ingredients. Perfectly portable, great for road trips, vacation, as well as packed lunches!
Homemade Uncrustables Sandwiches
My kids LOVE Uncrustables sandwiches - and I have to admit I do appreciate the convenience of them. But at around $3.97 for a box of four, I definitely do not appreciate the price...
So I set out to figure out how to make homemade Uncrustables to stock my freezer. Sure, it's easy enough to toss some basic peanut butter and jelly sandwiches in the freezer, but my kids prefer their sandwiches cut, crusts removed, and sealed.
Plus keeping them from getting soggy when they're defrosted is a bit of a challenge... But I have a solution to share!
"This is such a great idea!"
My kids love these things, but I refuse to pay that price! Thanks!

My Favorite Uncrustable Maker
I've used the Pampered Chef Cut-N-Seal in the past, but I wasn't totally satisfied with it. It made very small sandwiches and wasted a significant bread.
So when I spied this sandwich sealer (similar) at Walmart the other day, I figured it was worth a try. Weirdly, it was on one of those vertical hanging holders in a random grocery aisle. I checked the kitchen gadgets sections and it was not stocked there.
My kids were super excited to test it out. While it did fall short of the one-step sealing and cutting claim, I was happy that there was less wasted bread. And after a bit of trial and error, it easily produced perfectly cut and sealed peanut butter and jelly sandwiches!
NEW: I just stumbled across this round uncrustable maker online! It cuts and seals just like the square one I own.
I also found this 3-pc. sandwich sealer set that makes round, square, and triangle-shaped uncrustables. Plus it has a smaller cutter for cheese and deli meats, which seems really useful. If you try it, I'd love to hear what you think - it has excellent reviews!

How To Make Uncrustables
So what's the formula for making awesome homemade uncrustables? First things first - my secret to non-soggy thawed PB&J sandwiches...
The key is spreading a thin layer of peanut butter on both slices of bread. The peanut butter acts as a sealant, keeping the jelly from touching the bread. Which in turn prevents the sandwiches from getting soggy when defrosted!
Use about a tablespoon of jelly or preserves (slightly less if you're using honey) and keep it confined to the center of the bread. Be careful to not use too much jelly. Overfilling can cause the contents to burst through the top of the bread during the cutting and sealing steps.
We also discovered that larger sandwich bread loaves work best. The sandwich won't seal well if the crust is not completely trimmed off.
I've also used this method to make peanut butter and honey uncrustables and uncrustables with nutella for my picky 6-year-old. These turned out great, as well!

Using the Uncrustable Maker for Frozen PB&J
It's a little hard to tell in the photos, but the uncrustable maker is actually two separate pieces. I found that the sandwiches turn out the best when you cut and seal in two steps.
- Keep both pieces together, center them over your sandwich. Press down on the outside cutter piece to trim away the crusts and move them aside. If it doesn't cut completely through, wiggling the crust around while pressing down on the cutter should free it.
- Then press down firmly on just the center sealing piece to tightly seal the sandwich all the way around.
Placing a silicone baking mat on the cutting surface is helpful in preventing the sandwiches from sticking. AND it makes cleanup quick and easy!
Reader Tip: Get That Uncrustable-Like Texture
If you want your crustless PB&J sandwiches to have a texture that's more like an actual Uncrustable, use a rolling pin to flatten the bread out before assembling them. This will give them that "uncrustable" feel when you bite into them.
Thank you for sharing, Marianne!

Freezing An Uncrustable Sandwich
To freeze the sandwiches, simply lay them out individually on a cookie sheet and flash freeze them for about two hours. At this point you can transfer them all to a gallon food storage freezer bag or package them up in individual Ziploc sandwich bags.

How To Thaw Uncrustables
We make a point of making a boatload of these frozen PB&J every weekend. It saves a ton of money and time throughout the week. Now I have a freezer full of frozen peanut butter and jelly sandwiches for easy lunches for my on-the-go kids!
They thaw easily on their own in a packed lunch, or quick thaw them in the microwave for 15 seconds. Plus I love that I can control the quality of the ingredients in their sandwiches versus the store bought products.
Now to figure out what to do with all of the crusts... A French Toast casserole perhaps?
Printable Recipe ↓

Homemade Uncrustables Frozen PB&J Sandwiches
Ingredients
- creamy peanut butter
- strawberry preserves, or honey
- 2 loaves sliced sandwich bread
Instructions
To Make:
- Spread a thin layer of peanut butter on both slices of bread.
- Place about one tablespoon of jelly or preserves in the center of the bread. If I'm using honey, I will use slightly less because it's more runny.
- Top the jelly slice with the peanut butter only slice.
- Center a sandwich sealer over both slices of bread. Press down on the outside cutter piece to trim away the crusts and move them aside. Then press down on the center sealing piece to seal the sandwich all the way around.
To Freeze:
- Lay the sandwiches out individually on a cookie sheet and flash freeze them for about two hours.
- Transfer them to a gallon size freezer storage bag or package them up in individual sandwich bags.
- Sandwiches will thaw on their own by lunchtime. Or you can microwave them for 15 seconds to quick thaw.
Recipe Notes
Featured Products
More Kid-Friendly Snack Recipes
If you like this diy uncrustables recipe, you might also enjoy these other kid-friendly snack recipes:
Did you make this recipe?
I'd love to see how your homemade uncrustables turns out... Tag me @Unsophisticook on Instagram or use the hashtag #Unsophisticook so I can check it out. Enjoy!











Andrea says
Oh true, I guess it would be tricky! I only have one! But you would have to defrost it quick wouldn't you?!
Tara @ Unsophisticook says
Yeah, but they defrost in 15 seconds and all but my youngest know how to work the microwave now. (thank goodness!)
Andrea says
Aha! Well taught! lol :)
Andrea says
Why would you want to freeze sandwiches anyway? They take mere moments to make? Great idea with the gadget but don't get the freezing of the sarnies!!
Tara @ Unsophisticook says
I'm not sure about everyone else, but I have five kids that are always coming and going during the summer. I can't stop what I'm doing to make a sandwich every time one of them is ready for lunch, so it's much easier for me to make a bunch at the beginning of the week so they can grab them out of the freezer.
Robbie says
I would use the crust in my sausage & egg casserole that everyone loves. That would help with Breakfast & Lunch! Wahoo!
Did anyone figure up what the average cost of making these yourself would come out to be?
Heather says
Darn it! I am super excited to try this and I have been looking all over at every store I go to. No luck finding this. All I have been able to find is the shape maker like dinosaurs....Not to worry, I am not giving up on my quest! I am determined to make my own uncrustables!:)
jlong says
I make ours with a wide mouth cup and just make sure to pinch the edges together..works like a charm :)
marly says
What a great idea! I'm all for kids taking their own lunches vs. school lunches and having these handy sure would help there.
marguarita says
Great ideas. I plan on getting two of these asap. Giving one to my son who just moved out on his own who always begged me to buy the store ones. This way he can make up a whole bunch and freeze for later. The other one is for me because I like them too. Thanks for sharing !
curlyhair05 says
Thanks for the idea. I just went grocery shopping and found one at Safeway for $2.99 which I thought was okay since the nearest Walmart is 30 minutes away. My kids love these, but I hate the price for the ready made ones.
Domestic Diva says
Love this, Tara! Thanks for the how-to. Definitely going to try these when school starts back.
lisa says
Awesome idea Stephanie!! I bought mine 2 years back at my food store also, the cutters that are metal edged work better. Making mine today.
mama says
What a simple and great idea! I have a son allergic to peanuts, so we can't buy Uncrustables. But now we can make them with sunflower butter and jelly! I have the Pampered Chef cut and seal too, but it wastes too much bread. I will also try it with cream cheese and jelly to see how that works out. Thank you!
Mandy says
I have had one of those I picked up at Walmart a few years ago. It works great.
JANET RIDER says
I love love my Wonder sandwich maker. I think I found mine (also randomly hanging in an aisle) at Kroger...maybe 2.99? Well worth it. Can even make grilled cheese with them or like we used to make while camping...pizza pockets!! Not sure how well they would turn out but worth a try!! But fun! Take your crusts (which have a little pb and jelly in them), break them up and coat with eggs and bake like a casserole...then put a little syrup on them like french toast. I've seen in Family FUn Mag to bake or grill your pbj's and cut in strips and dip in syrup....same concept, yes?
colleen says
Awesome idea, and will allow me to get creative! I have 2 children with peanut allergies, and my others are not big fans,so I don't purchase uncrustables. Funny thing is only my baby doesnt like the crust, all my other children eat it! 3 of my children love and are able to have Nutella. Will have to see what I can come up with!
Tara @ Unsophisticook says
Mmm, maybe Nutella and mashed bananas?
Nikki says
Great idea. I'm going to try this too!
stephanie says
I'm thinking this would be great to make a big bag and take them to a new mom (who has other children as well). Then she can pull them out for a super easy lunch while tending to her newborn. I'm due w/ my 3rd in a few weeks and will definitely be making a bunch for my house before the big day. I'm sure I'll be eating them too (not just the kiddos)as I don't ever eat well the first few weeks after my babies are born. Thanks for the great post!
Tara @ Unsophisticook says
That's a fantastic idea, Stephanie! I would have been sooooo thankful if someone had handed me a few bags of these those first few days. Very thoughtful!
Pamela Maciejewski says
This is a freaking awesome idea - my kids love uncrustables and i hardly ever buy them cause of the cost so if i can find this at my walmart i am definitely going to try this and load my freezer up with them